Sugar Cookies

Daily

Pop into our shop daily to pick up adorable decorated sugar cookies and seasonal gift boxes for a birthday, holiday or just for fun.


Special Order

Create your customizable collection from our popular shapes below. Most collections include 1-3 designs.

Order Lead Time

We recommend ordering your cookies at least 1-2 weeks in advance. Short on time? Give us a ring and we'll try our best to squeeze you in. It's never too early to order.

Price

Our sugar cookies average $4.00 to $7.00 each with a minimum order of 24. Most ellenJAY cookie collections have 3 coordinating designs and are approximately $5 per cookie.

Packaging

Individual favor packaging with coordinating satin ribbon is an additional $1.00 per cookie. Gift boxes are $4.00 each.


Pick your shapes from any of these popular COOKIE CATEGORIES.

BIRTHDAY
Balloon
Cake Slice
Cupcake
Numbers (Age)
Party Hat
Present

BABY
Carriage
Christening Outfit - Girl
Christening Outfit - Boy
Cross
Lamb
Onesie
Rattle
Rubber Duck

WEDDING
Bridesmaid Dress
Flower
High Heel
Wedding Cake
Wedding Cake on Pedestal
Wedding Dress

FIESTA
Cactus
Cowboy Hat
Cowboy Boot
Pinata
Sombrero

NATURE
Cloud
Flower
Rainbow
Tree

MISC
Barn
Circus Tent
Pinwheel
Teepee
Tent

KIDS
Ballet Shoe
Castle
Crown
Construction Cone
Dinosaur
Hard Hat
Mermaid Tail
Pirate
Princess Dress
Tutu
Unicorn

BEACH/SUMMER
Flip Flop
Palm Tree
Sand Dollar
Shell
Starfish
Surf Board
Swim Suit
Swim Trunk

FOOD
Beer Mug
Coffee Mug
Cotton Candy
Gumball Machine
Hamburger
Hot Dog
Ice Cream Cone
Mason Jar
Pie
Pineapple
Pizza
Popcorn
Popsicle

TRANSPORTATION
Airplane
Bicycle
Car
Camper
Dumptruck
Firetruck
Hot Air Ballooon
Sailboat
Tractor

ANIMALS
Alligator
Bear
Crab
Crawfish
Cow
Deer
Dog Bone
Dog House
Elephant
Fish
Flamingo
Fox
Frog
Giraffe
Horse
Labrador
Lady Bug
Lion
Monkey
Owl
Paw Print
Pig
Puppy
Shark
Sheep
Turtle

SPORTS
Baseball
Baseball Glove
Baseball Field
Baseball Bat
Fishing Pole
Football
Football Field
Golf Bag
Helmet
Jersey
Mega Phone
Putting Green
Roller Skate


NEWSLETTER

Join the sweetest club around!